gutzmank

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 316 through 330 (of 642 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Manumission in 1860 #15370
    gutzmank
    Participant

    It wasn’t legal in Virginia., or in several other southern states. I can’t say that it was illegal in all.

    in reply to: Immigration #20813
    gutzmank
    Participant

    That’s correct. Yet, in the controversy over the Alien & Sedition Acts, Republicans such as Jefferson and Madison insisted that the Alien Friends Act was unconstitutional because it was up to the states to decide who immigrated until 1808.

    in reply to: Are the Article V calls just a Red Herring? #20826
    gutzmank
    Participant

    Gov. Deal of Georgia signed the Compact for America legislation the other day. 33 states to go.

    in reply to: U.S. History Textbook #15330
    gutzmank
    Participant

    I like WHERE WAS PATRICK HENRY ON THE 29TH OF MAY? Take a look.

    in reply to: Abolition of Slavery in Political Platforms before 1860 #15344
    gutzmank
    Participant

    You’re welcome.

    in reply to: Protective Tariffs #15348
    gutzmank
    Participant

    You’re welcome.

    in reply to: Are the Article V calls just a Red Herring? #20824
    gutzmank
    Participant

    This week, the lower house of the Alaska Legislature passed the CFA legislation. It joined one house of the Arizona Legislature. Georgia’s legislature has passed the legislation and sent it to Gov. Deal for his signature. This thing is on a roll. If your state legislature isn’t one of those three, I urge you to follow up with your rep(‘s)/senator(s).

    in reply to: Protective Tariffs #15346
    gutzmank
    Participant

    The North exported far fewer products than the South. >70% of American exports were southern agricultural goods–although they were generally carried in northern or British ships.

    in reply to: Abolition of Slavery in Political Platforms before 1860 #15342
    gutzmank
    Participant

    They denied wanting to end slavery. Their position was “No More Slave Territories.”

    The Liberty Party opposed slavery. No other did.

    in reply to: Daily Show Interview with Judge Naplitano #15350
    gutzmank
    Participant

    Sorry, but I didn’t see it.

    It is odd that the judge was put up against several professional experts in this field. Stacked deck?

    in reply to: McCarthyism and the Venona Cables #16089
    gutzmank
    Participant

    They validated his general claim. Besides that, virtually everyone who was blackballed was an actual Communist.

    Take a look at M. Stanton Evans’ McCarthy biography. Evans is an outstanding writer (and raconteur), and he has the goods.

    in reply to: Books regarding the wars #16077
    gutzmank
    Participant

    Alexander Werth’s RUSSIA AT WAR, 1941-45 Is excellent. The description of the Siege of Leningrad is unforgettable.

    in reply to: Once again: Yes, the stimulus worked #20187
    gutzmank
    Participant

    Assuming, arguendo, that the argument is right so far as it goes:

    “Worked” in what sense?

    No one disputes that with enough borrowing–that is, transferring wealth from the future to the present–one can jolt current consumption. Is this rocket science?

    Is there ever a point at which these people conclude that it’s immoral to pile more debt on posterity so that we can benefit today? (NB: rhetorical question)

    in reply to: Are the Article V calls just a Red Herring? #20822
    gutzmank
    Participant

    Since secession is impossible now, unlike in Speaker Macon’s time, the Compact for America initiative is our best option. Let me know what you think after you read my review of Levin’s book and the associated links.

    Yes, I do have a hard time believing that anyone sincerely thinks that an open-ended drafting convention would yield any results at all, let alone good results.

    in reply to: Article 1 Section 9 #20828
    gutzmank
    Participant

    It means that direct taxes are to be apportioned among the states according to their populations.

    Yes, the Federal Government does now essentially ignore this provision in regard to several types of taxation.

Viewing 15 posts - 316 through 330 (of 642 total)