October 22, 2012 at 10:04 pm #17277mariviwMember
What does it mean when these presidential candidates say China is a “currency manipulator”? Isn’t every country with a central bank a “currency manipulator”? Finally Obama said sanctions on Iran caused Iran’s currency to lose value by 80%. How can sanctions cause inflation?October 23, 2012 at 11:26 am #17278rtMember
Romney repeatedly called China a currency manipulator because China has artificially decreased the value of their currency (by increasing money supply). As a result the US Dollar might buy more Renminbis and it’s cheaper for Americans to buy Chinese products than American products. This is according to Romney. He does not mention that the Fed has decreased the purchasing power of the US Dollar for years and that other Central Banks do the same to the currencies of their countries. Moreover Romney said that he favored tariffs to make it more expensive for Americans to buy Chinese products which protects American industry. American consumers would undoubtedly be harmed.
Regarding Iran, a currency can not only fall due to an increase in the money supply but also due to a decreased demand. Sanctions are hurting the Iranian economy which results in a lower demand for the Iranian currency.October 24, 2012 at 3:25 pm #17279jmherbenerModerator
Such claims are part of the oft-refuted mercantilist view of international trade. Specifically, the claim that a nation is better off by exporting more than it imports. Whatever policies the state can impose that favor exports and discourage imports is justified. One such policy is for the state to make its currency cheaper in foreign exchange markets than dictated by its domestic purchasing power. Doing so stimulates exports by making domestic prices lower for foreigners who can trade their foreign currency for more of the domestic currency. This is what is meant by currency manipulation in international trade.
A state could use monetary inflation to manipulate its currency or it could use monetary inflation for other purposes. Monetary inflation stimulates exports only if it devalues the domestic currency against foreign exchange before it pushes domestic prices up. Usually this does happen because foreign exchange traders react more quickly to monetary inflation than the average domestic consumer. There are other ways besides monetary inflation to manipulate currencies. For example, a state could peg its domestic currency to a foreign currency at an artificially low level and then use tax revenues to supply more of its domestic currency in foreign exchange markets to keep its exchange rate at the peg. Of course, it’s more likely a state would print the additional money it wants to supply against foreign exchange. This is what China is accused of doing.
In addition to the reduced demand for Iranian Rial in foreign exchange markets, another way that sanctions push up prices in Iran is that they reduce the stock of goods Iranians have available to buy.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.