Reply To: Question on test

#19113
dmdavidmann
Member

Thank you for your help and patience.

And wow, that is a really good example that you just gave. Exactly what I was after

“PEQ
QIR
therefore POR”

It fails to satisfy rule six not because the P is undistributed in the conclusion and distributed in the major premise but because the R term is distributed in the conclusion and undistributed in the minor premise. Have I understood once and for all?